The wind off Cape Cod Bay has a particular quality in early April, before the tourists arrive, when the town is still coming awake from its winter and the tradespeople outnumber the vacationers by a ratio that will reverse within a month. It is cool. Not cold, but cool enough to require a sweater or hoodie, carrying the specific salt and seaweed smell of an ocean that has not yet warmed up for the season. I am sitting on the deck of a rented cottage with my sister. The day has been sunny from the start, only wispy, faint clouds dashing across the sky, the kind of clouds that do not threaten anything, that are there mostly to give the blue something to contrast against. And somewhere around late afternoon, as the temperature begins to drop and the wind picks up and the light shifts toward that particular evening quality that has no name in English, a feeling arrives in my chest that I have not felt in years, and that I recognize immediately.
It is melancholy. Not sadness, not depression, nothing with a clinical name. Just the quiet, anticipatory ache of something ending, or about to end, or already having ended in ways I cannot quite place. It is a feeling I have not had since childhood, and the childhood it belongs to is very specific: end-of-summer nights at a cabin on Perch Lake in northern Minnesota, where my family were caretakers, and where the first cool nights of August always carried the same message, the same unwelcome whisper that summer was closing up shop and school was coming, and whatever this thing was that I had been trying to hold onto all summer was slipping through my hands.
I have not thought about Perch Lake in a long time. And then the wind picked up, and I was there again.
Perch Lake was not ours. We were the caretakers, my family, which meant that in exchange for maintaining the cabin and the grounds, for mowing the grass and clearing the brush and closing the place up for winter and opening it again in spring, we got to use it ourselves when the owners were not there. This arrangement had the particular generosity of small-town Minnesota: a handshake deal, an unspoken trust, the assumption that you would treat the thing as if it were yours while remembering always that it was not. We did. We treated it as if it were ours, and we remembered that it was not, and the balance between those two things was part of what made the cabin feel like a place we had earned rather than a place we owned.
At the end of every summer, when the owners were done for the season, we would stay there for a few days, sometimes a week. This was the best time to be at the cabin, in the particular in-between when the days were still warm enough for swimming and the nights had begun their slow migration toward autumn. The loons were still calling at dusk. The water was still warm enough to be tolerable at noon and cold enough to take your breath away first thing in the morning. The mosquitoes had mostly thinned out. The light in the late afternoon had that specific slanted quality that August light has in Minnesota, the kind that tells you, without needing to say it, that the year has turned and is now moving in a different direction.
I loved the cabin. I loved the water. I loved the particular smell of the place, the combination of pine and lake and old woodsmoke from the fires we had near the shore. I loved waking up early and walking down to the dock while everyone else was still asleep and watching the mist come off the water in the kind of silence that only exists in places far from roads.
And I hated the end of the trip, because the end of the trip meant the end of summer, and the end of summer meant school.
I should say something about school, because the feeling I am trying to describe was inseparable from the knowledge that school was coming, and I want to be clear about what that meant and what it did not.
I was not a bullied kid. I was not a kid who dreaded school because school was hostile territory. I was good at school, in the particular way that smart kids are good at school, which is to say that the academic work was not a problem and often was not even a challenge, and the teachers generally liked me because I was the kind of student who made their job easier. I was not afraid of tests. I was not afraid of homework. I was not afraid of being called on in class.
What I was afraid of, though “afraid” is not quite the right word, was the social apparatus of school. The lunchroom. The hallway between classes. The recess yard. The particular Darwinian geometry of children arranging themselves into groups based on rules that I could read from a distance but could not reliably apply from inside. I did not have a stable place in that apparatus, or I had a place but the place felt provisional, conditional, revocable without notice. I was not picked on. I was just not quite of the group, whichever group I happened to be adjacent to at any given time, and the provisional quality of my membership was something I was aware of long before I had the vocabulary to describe it.
I liked the teachers more than I liked the other kids. This is the kind of thing you are not supposed to say out loud, because it sounds either pretentious or sad or both, and because it violates the quiet social contract of childhood that says your peers are supposed to be the center of your world. But it is true, and the essays I have been writing here have been, among other things, an exercise in saying the true thing even when it does not flatter. The teachers were adults. They operated by rules I understood. Their interest in me was based on things I could produce: answers, questions, curiosity, effort. The other kids were operating on a different system, one that valued things I did not have, things I could not fake, things that seemed to have to do with social fluency and athletic ability and the particular confidence of being the right kind of kid in the right kind of moment. I was not the right kind of kid. I was the kind who would rather talk to the teacher during recess than run around the playground, and the teachers understood this even when my classmates did not.
So school, for me, was not hostile. It was just exhausting in a way I could not name. It was the daily obligation of navigating a social environment whose rules I could not reliably parse, while also doing the academic work, which I could, and the mismatch between my competence at the two halves of the experience created a specific kind of quiet tension that I carried with me for years. The summers at the lake were the release from that tension. And the end of summer was the signal that the tension was about to return, and the signal arrived, every year, in the form of cool wind coming off the water in late August.
I think now that what I was feeling as a child was not only the ordinary dread of school returning. I think it was also the underlying architecture of schizoaffective disorder doing its early work in a brain that had not yet learned what it was.
Anxiety and paranoia are, I have since learned, central features of the condition I was eventually diagnosed with. They do not wait for adulthood to announce themselves. They show up in childhood, in adolescence, in the small and unaccountable apprehensions of a kid who cannot explain why the shortening of the days feels like a threat, why the cool wind carries a weight it should not carry, why the transition from one season to another triggers something that looks, from the outside, like normal end-of-summer melancholy but that on the inside has a slightly sharper edge, a slightly deeper pull, a quality that ordinary sadness does not have. Most kids feel the end of summer. My feeling had a few extra degrees of charge, and I did not know it had extra degrees of charge, because it was the only feeling I had ever had, and you do not know your baseline is off until you have something to compare it to.
The lizard brain is the cheap shorthand for what was happening. The limbic system, the part of the brain that responds to environmental cues before the conscious mind can interpret them. The cool air drops. The light shifts. The body registers the change, and the brain that is attached to the body sends signals that something is wrong, that something is ending, that something needs to be prepared for even when there is nothing specific to prepare for. Most brains handle this by producing a mild, ordinary melancholy. My brain handled it by producing something that approached but did not quite become a clinical response. A hairline crack of anxiety, running through the otherwise ordinary transition from summer to fall, that I did not know was symptomatic because no one had told me there was anything to be symptomatic about.
I did not know there was a name for what I was feeling. I would not know for another twenty years. At the cabin, at the end of summer, I just knew that the wind off the lake carried something I did not want, and I stood on the dock anyway, and watched the loons, and waited for it to pass.
My sister left for college in the mid-nineties, when I was still in high school, and the departure inaugurated a pattern that has now held for nearly thirty years. She would be somewhere. I would go visit her. The first trips were simple and practical. I would drive from the Iron Range to Fargo, where she had an apartment, and spend a weekend or a week away from home and away from school and away from whatever version of myself I had been assembling in the particular pressure cooker of rural Minnesota adolescence. The drive itself was part of it. Four or five hours of flat highway, Minnesota giving way to North Dakota giving way to the western edge of the plains, and at the end of the drive there was an apartment where the rules were different and the social geometry of high school did not apply.
The trips got bigger. We went to Finland, walked through Helsinki in the long summer evenings when the sun refused to fully set. We went to Japan, where the vending machines sold hot coffee and the trains ran with a precision that felt like a rebuke to every other country’s attempt at rail service. We went to Vietnam, to the humid streets of Hanoi and the terraced rice paddies of the north, and ate food that I cannot reproduce at home even when I try. We went to the Maritimes, to Halifax and Cape Breton and the Bay of Fundy, where the tide does things that look like special effects but are just geography. We have been to countless destinations in the United States, road trips and flights and the particular dialect of two siblings who have been navigating unfamiliar places together long enough that the logistics have become automatic and the conversation has become the point.
Which is how I ended up in Provincetown. She wanted to see it in the off-season, before the tourists arrived, when the town was quiet and the prices were reasonable and the locals were still happy to see you. We rented a cottage on the bay side. We will have been here for two days and one night by the time we leave, which is not a long stay by any measure but is, as it turns out, exactly long enough for the place to do its work on you. The town is bustling, but not with visitors. It is bustling with the tradespeople who are doing the work that the visitors will not see: painting the cottages, fixing the plumbing, pruning the hedges, patching the roofs, performing the particular off-season maintenance that keeps a tourist town ready to perform tourism when the tourists arrive.
We walked over three miles today, our first day, from the cottage into the center of town and back, stopping to look at things, taking in the layered history of a place that has been, at various times, a refuge for artists and writers and gay men and now also wealthy tourists and pre-tourist tourists like us. By the time we got back to the cottage, we were tired in the particular, pleasant way that comes from walking a new place on foot. We had every intention of going back out for dinner, finding somewhere local, the kind of place a person writes down in a notebook so they can recommend it to someone else later.
We called our mom in Minnesota first. We talked for a while, the three of us layered across the country by phone, catching up on the ordinary things that a mother and her two adult children catch up on when the children are traveling together. The conversation ran longer than we expected, the way conversations with people you love often do. By the time we hung up, the sun had started its downward trend and the temperature outside was dropping and the wind off the bay had picked up to the extent that the sliding doors, which we had left open to the ocean, were letting in a cold breeze that had turned the cottage into something that was not quite indoor temperature anymore.
Meghann was hunkered under a jacket on the couch. The breeze came in. The light was doing its evening thing. And she looked at me and said, “Do we really want to go back out? I’m quite comfortable right now.” Which was a rhetorical question, and the answer was no, we did not really want to go back out, and we ordered pizza instead.
I like Provincetown. The off-season is honest about itself. It shows you the bones of the place, the work that holds it up, the people who actually live here when the crowds are not distracting from the answer to the question of who lives here.
And this afternoon, sitting on the deck, the wind came up off the bay and the temperature dropped and the light shifted, and something in me lurched.
Not dramatically. Not in a way that would have been visible to anyone watching. Just a small, internal pivot, a feeling arriving like a memory from a different life, and for a moment I could not place it. Then I placed it. Perch Lake. The cabin. The end of summer. The cool wind coming off the water while I stood on the dock and knew, without having to be told, that something was ending and something else was coming, and the something else was school, and the school was a place I did not want to go, and the not wanting was a thing I could not explain even to myself.
The feeling in Provincetown was the same feeling. But it was less intense than the feeling at the lake. That is the thing I want to get at. It was recognizable, unmistakably the same, but dimmer, thinner, more manageable. It arrived. I noticed it. I sat with it. And it did not escalate. It did not become anxiety. It did not become paranoia. It did not become the particular unnameable dread that sometimes became, at the lake, the thing that would keep me awake in the bed in the cabin listening to the loons and the wind, waiting for the summer to officially end so the dread could stop being anticipation and start being an actual thing I was experiencing.
The difference is medication and therapy and the accumulated work of twenty-plus years of learning what my brain does and what it means when it does it. The lizard brain still fires. The environmental cues still reach it. The temperature still drops and the light still shifts and some ancient part of me still responds to the signal that a summer is ending, even when the summer is not technically mine and the lake is an ocean and I am sitting on a deck in Massachusetts with my sister instead of on a dock in Minnesota with my family. The response is contained now. It does not amplify. It does not spiral. It does not reach for the old anxieties and build them into something larger. It arrives, it is noticed, it is allowed to be what it is, and then it passes.
This is what maintenance looks like, I think, at its best. Not the absence of the old feelings. Not a triumphant victory over a brain that has been trying to do its old tricks. Just the moderation of the response. The feeling still gets through. But it gets through at a volume I can handle, and it leaves when its time is up, and it does not take the rest of my afternoon with it.
My sister is inside the cottage, reading. The wind is still coming off the bay. The light has that particular evening quality that I now associate with two places: a lake in northern Minnesota in August, and a rented cottage in Provincetown in April. They are not the same place. The feeling that connects them is not, technically, the same feeling. But the feeling is close enough to the old one that I recognize it, and the recognition is not painful. It is almost welcome. It is evidence that the child I used to be is still in here somewhere, still responsive to the same signals, still capable of being moved by the shortening of a day in a way that does not require a clinical explanation.
Melancholy is a word that has fallen out of fashion. It sounds archaic, vaguely Victorian, like something you would diagnose with leeches or blame on an imbalance of humors. But the word is useful because it names a specific state that other words do not quite capture: not sadness, not depression, not grief. Just the quiet ache of time passing, of summers ending, of the particular awareness that everything you are currently experiencing will soon be something you remember rather than something you live in. It is a feeling every person eventually feels, and I am grateful, in a way I did not expect to be grateful for something so small, to be in the category of people who get to feel it now the way most people feel it. Mildly. Accurately. Without the old amplification.
The tide will crest. The wind will keep blowing. The pizza will arrive and we will eat it with the sliding doors closed now against the cold. Tomorrow morning we will walk the beach, head up to the Pilgrim Monument, and then start the drive back to eastern Connecticut, the cottage fading in the rearview mirror the way all the places on these trips eventually fade, filed alongside Helsinki and Hanoi and Halifax and all the other destinations my sister and I have accumulated across thirty years of going somewhere together. The cool wind will still be doing its quiet work on my brain, reaching the old places, firing the old circuits. But the circuits fire differently now. The signal arrives and the response is proportional, and that proportion is the difference between a feeling I can sit with on a deck in Provincetown and a feeling that used to keep me awake in cabin waiting for summer to officially end so I could stop dreading the end of it.
It is a small difference. It is also the entire difference. And I am sitting with it, here, in the off-season, watching the light go, feeling the old melancholy arrive at the volume I can finally afford.
Quiet Mind, Loud Brain 
Leave a comment